Skip to product information
1 of 1

Pigeon Baking Company

Oatmeal Cream Pies

Oatmeal Cream Pies

Regular price $11.00 USD
Regular price Sale price $11.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Number of Sandwiches

Our brown sugar oatmeal cookies get an upgrade with some oatmeal and a delicious cream filling. The perfect partnership between childhood nostalgia and new beginnings!

Every order is made to order and is "marinated" for 24-48 hours to allow the flavors to set in. This process yields one of the tastiest cookies you'll ever try. Perfect for events and family gatherings!

DETAILS

- Cookies will stay soft and fresh at room temperature in a closed container or original packaging for up to 7 days. They freeze extremely well for up to 2 months. Each order comes with "care instructions" on my recommendation on how to enjoy them the most! Each cookie is wrapped individually.

SHIPPING INFORMATION

Items ship by either Ground Advantage (2-5 day) or Priority Mail 2-3 day domestic (or other mailing service such as UPS) up to a week internationally depending on how much you spend on shipping. You may purchase expedited shipping at your own expense (USPS Priority Mail Express or UPS Next Day). Some items not available outside the US. Items are individually packaged for freshness. They may ship with ice packs, if applicable, however additional ice packs are recommended during hot summer months. We reserve the right to downgrade shipping to a lower tier for non-expedited shipping if the cost difference would cause a monetary loss on the order.

All shipping costs are non-refundable, even if you received free shipping. This is due to the nature of our products, which are not covered under shipping insurance.

INGREDIENT LIST

Flour, Dark brown sugar, butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla, molasses, baking soda, salt

FILLING

Powdered Sugar, Butter, Heavy cream, Vanilla, Salt

ALLERGEN INFORMATION

Contains wheat, soy, milk, and egg. If you have a unique allergy, please message me and I can provide you all the details for the ingredients that you need to make you feel at ease. I am trained in cross-contamination food service protocol if needed.

QUESTIONS?

Feel free to message me and I'll be happy to help!

Thank you so much for shopping at Pigeon Baking Company and joining the flock!

Customer Reviews

Based on 22 reviews
95%
(21)
5%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
S
Sydney L
AMAZING!!!!

We bought a bunch of Pigeon Baking Company cookies for our wedding last month, we bought 250, and we came home with less than 20, we had a 100 person wedding! Everything was just so wonderfully made and absolutely delicious, we plan on buying them for every event going forward. The Oatmeal Cream Pies, the Oatmeal Raisin, and the Carrot Cake bars we’re our favorites! Goldy helped us place the order and she went so above and beyond with our questions or any information we needed! 10/10, will be a forever customer!

F
Florian
The pies are excellent. They remind me of...

The pies are excellent. They remind me of old fashioned oatmeal pies

A
Athena
Good stuff! Pecan pie bars were my favouri...

Good stuff! Pecan pie bars were my favourite

A
Alda
Very good and as expected

Very good and as expected

K
Kimberly
The cookie sandwiches weren't exactly like...

The cookie sandwiches weren't exactly like the picture but they were delicious. I couldn't help but indulge in these delights. I would order them again.

View full details